Excited about #ForgeFed but unsure what the status is? 😅
Want to help but unsure how? 🤔
Wondering what's separating us from having a fediverse of forges? 🤓
How do we, the free software community, stop depending on proprietary centralized tools and switch over to a free, by-the-people, decentralized hosting and collaboration platform?
I have an idea: Let's start doing biweekly/monthly community meetings! What do you think?
Please vote, and also comment and share your thoughts 😊
As you asked for my thoughts: sourcehut already exists and works. No need for another solution for an already solved problem.
@musicmatze @forgefed what would you say is left to be done, or what's required, to have sourcehut replace githu8 and the other centralized proprietary forges? Why are so many people still using githu8, gitlab.com or even their own GitLab CE/Gitea server, and how do we as a community switch everyone to sourcehut instances?
> just find intuitively on Sourcehut everything they expect?
> Will they know how to submit [...]?
Reason is that #shithub educated them a really bad and messy workflow, nothing clean and _git_ tailored.
> Since Sourcehut can't federate
False. Email is federated and so is git. #sourcehut is just a UI for those two.
What makes the githu8 workflow bad and messy? Not taking a side, just asking. Side note and nice reminder for ourselves, the workflow needs to be ultimately _human_ tailored.
And that "false" there - It seems you have a strong opinion about git & email & how they should be used? I respect that, but can we still look at the facts with honesty?
I mean, the fact is, Sourcehut doesn't federate with most other forges, and they don't federate with Sourcehut. Because most forge websites seem to be Gitea and GitLab, which don't federate, with any protocol. So I just mean, if we want to switch to email based federation with a web UI like Sourcehut's, we need to either implement this federation in more web forges, or decide it's going to be a Sourcehut-only federation (kind of like a Postfix-only email federation or a Mastodon-only short-text-message federation). No sidrbtakrn, jist pointingbthis out. What is our vision? ^_^
Whoops, *no side taken, pointing out
Yeah, git federates via email just fine, but, e.g. can users from gitea.io, gitlab.com, sr.ht etc. etc. use the web UI to open issues on each other's projects? Comment? Submit patches? etc. etc.
They can't, they don't inter-operate. At least so far. That's what I mean by no federation.
There's no web UI from other forges to sourcehut and there's no need for it, because this would require people to register on at least one of forges to contribute, whereas with the current approach you only need an email address.
This Mastodon instance is for people interested in technology. Discussions aren't limited to technology, because tech folks shouldn't be limited to technology either!